February 17, 2010
Born out of a homesickness for the yogurt of his native Iceland, Siggi Hilmarsson started to make his own batches at home, founding Siggi’s in 2005. After many, many batches, he was able to create a nonfat skyr with three times the amount of protein compared to standard yogurts.
It has the cleanest taste (and thickest texture!) of any dairy product I’ve ever tasted, and quickly developed a cult following among foodies and healthy eaters. Now distributed nationally by Whole Foods, I sat down with Siggi to discuss his perspectives on American tastebuds and approach to eating.
——————————————————————————————-
What was the inspiration for you behind founding your own yogurt company?
I missed skyr the yogurt of Iceland, which is much thicker than regular yogurt from being strained– you strain about 75% of the whey weight out so you have a much more concentrated mass of milk solids. Skyr is traditionally made from skim milk, because it’s a byproduct of butter. So back in Iceland in the old days, you would start by skimming off the cream to make butter, then take the skim and make the skyr, after straining the whey from the skyr you would use the whey to drink or pickle various sheep’s parts usually or other food items to store over the winter.
Although I missed skyr the reason why I founded Siggi’s as a particular brand of skyr in the US has more to do with food here than with yogurt per se—I’m pretty averse to eating a lot of sweet stuff and I wanted to make the product not very sweet. I wanted to make a yogurt that was not excessively sweet and didn’t have this explosive sweet flavor.
I don’t like eating a lot of sugar. And when I came to the States, I was shocked by not just candy, but whole wheat bread (with high fructose corn syrup) and everything in between has sugar. In particular even natural yogurt had 25 to 30 grams of sugar a cup. And then you see some that use aspartame, or artificial sweeteners, which I absolutely abhor. I don’t think they are good for you, they taste terrible, and they are part of this engineered food that I’m not really into.

How did you educate yourself in the process of making skyr?
I started just reading about it. My mom went to a couple local libraries back home in Iceland and got me some really old articles. I read some books, I read online, learned about yogurt in general. And then I started experimenting. All in all, from the time I made my first batch to when I started selling it, it was probably a year and a half. I went through many batches that failed first.
As a company, what are your guiding principles?
We don’t want any of our foods to be overly or excessively sweet, so we use a low amount of any sort of sugar substance. And the sugar we do put in there, we decided to use agave, which is a low glycemic carbohydrate, it takes the body longer to break down so basically you don’t get as much of a rush as you would if you just pump yourself up with sugar.
The other principles are general subtlety—we don’t use flavorings or try to avoid them, we use real fruit, don’t use any colorings, no artificial ingredients, try to keep ingredient style clear and short.
Even things that are unnecessary we just don’t include—for example people will often add beet juice for color, which is still natural and it’s pretty tasteless in small amounts, but we’ve skipped that. We don’t try to exaggerate the colors of things. Also with our sourcing we try to be transparent and traceable. We have certain criteria for the farms that they give their cows access to pasture, grass feed them, don’t use any hormones, we are against tail docking which is a rather unpleasant practice in some industrial dairies. We endorse sustainability–for the lack of a better word -and humane animal treatment, no factory farming.
Why is this principle of not adding more important to you?
I think there is a certain way you should eat, and we’ve trailed away from it by creating this exaggerated feeling of what a food is. My ideal situation is that I make yogurt with fruit and that’s pretty much it, I don’t try to make it anything that it is not. A lot of yogurt products have something like “wild fruit berry blast” and the ingredients are just sugar and artificial flavor. And then you would give people real raspberries and blueberries and then they would say, this is tasteless.
In some ways, the exaggeration of flavor destroys the palate…
It’s funny when you can buy a pack of chewing gum and ironically enjoy it. But when children or something think this is the way blueberries actually taste you’re skewing the whole system. Don’t take it as though I’m against flavor. I’m all for flavor when it’s real.
——————————————————————————————–
Historically American tastes have run less yogurty, do you feel this is changing?
Yes, I would say so. One indicator is the reception of our yogurt, the consumer feedback we get—appreciation that there’s a yogurt that is not so sweet, that doesn’t have artificial sweeteners. The reception has been way better than I ever anticipated when we first started.
In general, since I moved here 7 years ago, people are more aware of how food is made, and even if there’s a recession now I don’t think people are going to be turning back. I am not a fan of the word “holistic” but the move into a more knowledge about food, not just reading the label but knowing the ingredients, the source of the ingredients, caring about the way in which the food was made, caring about the ethics of animals, just the whole package. I think awareness is growing phenomenally.
Yogurt has been around for all civilization, but only recently has become a healthy food. Why is this so?
Well, this is only in America. Yogurt has always been around in Europe. The consumption of yogurt there is 4 to 5 times greater per person than it is here. It’s more a traditional part of the diet, like yogurt and cereal for breakfast. It has only recently begun to catch up in the US in the past 15 or 20 years, as Americans started to view it as part of eating “healthy.” One reason is probiotics, or friendly bacteria. Number two is calcium—yogurt is easier to digest than drinking milk, which has also become a popular source of protein in the diet, people are realizing the importance of having enough protein.
Personally you’re a healthy eater–what are some foods or routines you’re into?
I try to stay from very processed foods….I eat a lot of dark chocolate but never candy bars…I’m really into fish—I’m from Iceland, it’s like a big fishing village! I was brought up on fish, maybe as a teenager you rebel against it a little. You just want to order pizza, and then you come back to it.
I eat a lot of spinach, I like whole grain stuff, whole grain couscous, quinoa…a very basic meal I eat all the time is a fried fish with a bit a butter, salt and pepper, whole grain couscous, and spinach and avocado. For breakfast, I love the Ezekiel cereal…it just makes me feel good. I’ve been eating it for two or three years, add a little bit of milk and raisins, maybe some dried fruit.
Do you view Siggi’s as a luxury product, and do you have plans to introduce more affordable products in the future?
I don’t view it as a luxury, it is what it is for a reason. It’s a way of eating that includes ingredients that are more expensive. In particular there’s the straining process which uses three to four times the amount of milk used in regular yogurt. You would never complain if you got this much espresso versus this much drip coffee—It’s not the same product. If you wanted to get the same amount of protein from a regular yogurt as a strained yogurt like skyr, you would have to eat three of the regular yogurts and then you would have close to the same cost.
We are still small but and my hope is that as we grow a bit more efficient our products can become more approachable price wise, but not so if it means compromising on our values. A McDonalds hamburger is very cheap relatively, but I don’t share the same value system that might be needed to get our yogurt that cheap.
Any other interesting applications of skyr that you’ve tried out or heard of?
One of my favorites things is Mexican food, using it as a substitute for sour cream—fantastic! Or as a substitute when making a hearty soup, great for making healthy pancakes. You make pancakes and fill them with skyr and some dried fruit. One favorite I’ve done is with Bellinis, where I put a little bit of fish roll on top with skyr, topped with red onion and capers.
Do you think food is going to become more engineered in the future or go the other direction?
I think foods are going to go the other way [less pharmaceutical in nature] maybe not the other way but I think people will seek real food, they might eat it for a certain benefit. But people will want to eat an apple, or a bag nuts, or a salad.
There will always be a market for convenience food, but I think we’re going to move more into eating yogurt, having cheese, having fish, having bread…Just the notion that people want to start eating food that is grown and made as food, not an unidentifiable mass that is shaped like something that was stuff that is supposed to taste like something.
If this was some sort of art, it’s a move to minimalism and realism.
Thanks Siggi! Photo credit by Ruvan Wijesooriya.